Wednesday, September 30, 2015

As the world spins


Much has happened since I was forced by a very busy schedule to go on hiatus. 
  1. Michael Voris et al completed their "attack ads" against the SSPX.  I found it amusing that (if I read correctly) all of the 'witnesses' interviewed concluded that the SSPX is not in a formal state of schism.  Funny that.  I'm going to pull together some of the highlights in a series on the 'Arrested Development' of CMTV as 'Traditional' Catholics.

Thursday, September 24, 2015

Active Participation - New Mass vs Tridentine Mass


Rorate has posted a piece by Dr. Lamont worth reading here about active participation in the liturgy.

This is one of the cultural divides between the Pre/Post conciliar cultures - participating in the liturgy. Some would think (erroneously) that it means that laity should share more of the roles and responsibilities of the Priest (ie usurp).

Answer: Wrong.

Dr. Lamont provides insight to this phenom and a perspective that is needed in the Church today!


Wednesday, September 23, 2015

The Synod Runup: Keeping Oriented in the midst of disorientation


Ok so the Synod looms large on our radar screens (ok but not CMTV's - they've turned their targeting radar on the SSPX).

What to do?
Watch and pray lest you to enter into temptation.
I would also advocate studying the faith and keeping up with your spiritual reading.  Without these elements the risk of falling onto either side of the pinnacle of virtue is great.

Simple words, simple solution.

Implement them and practice the virtues and you will be safe.  I quickly reviewed my list of the virtues and identified the ones that (at first glance) I believe are critical to remaining faithful in this crisis.   See this link for the complete series on virtues.


Concert Announcement - Tomas Luis de Victoria's 1605 Requiem (September 26th, 2015)


Music reflects the values and culture of the composer and it is obvious that the Tridentine Mass had a profound influence on the composers to create beautiful settings for the Sacrifice of the Mass.

I received a copy of this advertisement from a friend in Winnipeg and encourage all Catholics in the area to attend what, I am certain, will be a wonderful experience.


Monday, September 21, 2015

Spirit of Archbishop Lefebvre


As a remedy for the vitriol emanating from MV/CMTV et al, perhaps we should understand the SSPX as their founder understood them ...


“The savage and unjust struggle, undertaken against the Society (of St. Pius X) by those who are trying to contaminate the Church’s sources of sanctification, merely confirms the Society’s authenticity. These persons are the successors of Cain, who wish anew to rid themselves of Abel, whose prayers God finds so agreeable.

“Today,…one of the most painful phenomena of our age is desecration—the desecration pursued by Freemasonry through secularization, atheism, rationalism, and now, tragically, aided by the clergy themselves. With God, and all that reminds us of God, being gradually eliminated and replaced by a denatured man, Society thus becomes a hell.  Living within the atmosphere of such a world, the Society of St. Pius X, in resurrecting the true spirit of the Church, seeks to show forth Our Lord Jesus Christ by restoring the honor due to consecrated persons and sacred things.We find edification in the holy places, the ceremonies, the chant, the choice of prayers from the Missal, the Breviary, the Pontifical and the Ritual. How could a soul, that lives by faith and seeks to model its faith upon that of the Church, seek to desecrate all this?Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre. 

Below is a compilation of five articles written by Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre in which he outlines to the SSPX's members the spirit of their priestly society, first published by the District of the USA.

Article no.1

Dear Friends,

Without doubt, these words are primarily addressed to the priests of the Society, but they are intended for the Society’s seminarians, brothers, sisters, novices, oblates and all who help us in our apostolate and participate in the spiritual life of the family.

On the occasion of the 10th anniversary of the Society, I would like to try to define and describe that which we call the "Spirit of the Society".

At times here and there, we hear the more or less sharp criticisms of our friends, who say:

“The members of the Society look upon themselves as privileges persons, they imagine for themselves to be the Church, and so they have little concern for others; they seek to possess everything, to control everything etc….”

It is possible that youth and a lack of experience in the apostolate sometimes provokes a tactlessness and causes misunderstandings. And it is certain that we must do all we can to show a charity towards those, who like ourselves, are striving to combat error and keeping the Faith.

But, that apart, it is useful to see where the Society stands within the present context of the Church, so that we might also be eventually ready to live within a new context, without modifying anything of our being of the Church and in the Church.

Having been recognized by the Church as a "Priestly Society of Common Life without vows", our Society has been grafted upon the trunk of the Church. It is drawing upon its sap of sanctification from the most authentic sources of the Church’s Tradition and the pure, living sources of holiness, following the footsteps of so many other societies that have gained ecclesiastical recognition over the centuries, whose branches have grown and blossomed and born fruits of sanctity for the honor of the Church militant and triumphant.

The savage and unjust struggle, undertaken against the Society by those who are trying to contaminate the Church’s sources of sanctification, merely confirms the Society’s authenticity. These persons are the successors of Cain, who wish anew to rid themselves of Abel, whose prayers God finds so agreeable.

In normal times, the foundation and development of our Society would have passed unnoticed among many other marvelous, fruitful and flourishing societies. Today, the dried-up, sterile, bitter fruits of most branches are a stark contrast to the vigor and life of traditionalist branches.

Thus the situation of the Society of St. Pius X in the Church puts it in a special place, something which is well understood by the faithful as a whole, who clearly manifest their desire of being evangelized and sanctified by the Society. This greatly encourages and consoles us, to see an ever increasing number of priests, who are not members of the Society, manifesting a desire of working with the Society, and thereby finding a spiritual strength, and the help and assurance of not being isolated.

The place of the Society, in relation to the Church, is one of considerable importance, since it legitimizes its continuity and the maintenance of its apostolate along the unchangeable line of its approved foundation by the Church. It would be most useful for us to define the Society, for it represents, by the grace of God, a hope for the Church and a hope for souls.

I have written these few lines intending them to be a kind of prologue for what is to appear in successive issues of the Cor Unum.

+Marcel Lefebvre
February 7, 1981

Article no. 2

The spirit of the Society, being above all that of the Church, will see to it that the members of the Society—priests, brothers, sisters, oblates and tertiaries—will ever increase in their knowledge of the Mystery of Christ, such as St. Paul describes in his epistles, especially those to the Ephesians and the Hebrews.

Then we shall discover what has guided the Church for 20 centuries, we will understand the importance the Church gives to the Sacrifice of Our Lord and consequently, to the Priesthood too! We will penetrate the depths of the great mystery of our Faith, the Holy Mass, and so to have limitless devotion for this mystery, making it the center of our thoughts, our hearts and our interior life and in thus doing so, living by the spirit of the Church.

All Scripture focuses upon the Cross, with its redeeming victim, shining with glory. All the life of the Church is turned towards the altar of Sacrifice and, consequently, the Church’s principal concern is for the sanctity of Her priests.

These are also the fundamental convictions of the Society. All its efforts and preoccupation with priories, schools, and above all, seminaries, are consecrated towards the formation of future priests.

The ever-increasing unveiling of the great mysteries for which they are destined, should give their lives an especial character; captivated by Our Lord and His sacrifice, they must by that very fact leave the world behind, with its vanities and futility, and show this detachment by their dress, their attitude, their love of silence and seclusion, even if, at a later date, the apostolic demands will require them to go to souls.

The spirit of the Church focuses upon the divine and the sacred. She forms the one who will give sacred things to others—sacerdos or sacra dans—the one who will perform holy and sacred acts—sacrum faciens. She places, in his consecrated hands, divine and sacred gifts, sacramenta, the Sacraments.

The Church consecrates and gives a sacred character to the baptized, the confirmed, to kings, virgins, knights, churches, chalices and altar stones. All these consecrations are done in the splendor of the Sacrifice of Our Lord and in the person of Jesus Himself.

Today, however, one of the most painful phenomena of our age is desecration—the desecration pursued by Freemasonry through secularization, atheism, rationalism, and now, tragically, aided by the clergy themselves. With God, and all that reminds us of God, being gradually eliminated and replaced by a denatured man, Society thus becomes a hell.  Living within the atmosphere of such a world, the Society of St. Pius X, in resurrecting the true spirit of the Church, seeks to show forth Our Lord Jesus Christ by restoring the honor due to consecrated persons and sacred things.

The sacred and the divine inspire respect. One of the characteristics of the Society will be that of showing respect towards baptized souls, of treating sacred things with respect, especially concerning the sacred action par excellence: the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.

Therefore, we will avoid being drawn into the current of vulgarity and crudeness—fruits of desecration. Respect for ourselves and for others, will be an especial sign of the true spirit of the Church. Both believers and non-believers will be greatly influenced by this manifestation of the spirit of the Church and Our Lord. Therein we truly see the Christian spirit and Christian civilization—a civility of respect, founded upon faith towards the sacred and divine, that is to say, towards Our Lord, all that represents Him and all that comes from Him.

+Marcel Lefebvre
June 2, 1981

Article no. 3

Profoundly convinced that the source of life is found in Christ crucified, and thus in the Sacrifice of that He has bequeathed to us, the members of the Society will uncover the precious legacy, with an ever increasing joy that the Mystical Spouse of Our Lord, born of Jesus’ pierced side, has wished to hand down with a splendor inspired of the Holy Ghost. Whence come the splendors of the liturgy, that sing of the crucified and risen Christ. The Church knows how to present and make us live these mysteries in a truly divine manner, in a way that our hearts are captivated and our souls uplifted. All has been thought out with the love of a faithful spouse and merciful mother. We find edification in the holy places, the ceremonies, the chant, the choice of prayers from the Missal, the Breviary, the Pontifical and the Ritual. How could a soul, that lives by faith and seeks to model its faith upon that of the Church, seek to desecrate all this?

The members of the Society, in their attachment to this spirituality of the Church written on stone and in traditional liturgical books, will not only strive to apply those spiritual principles to themselves, but will also uncover those wonders to the faithful.

The consequences of this attachment to the liturgy will be seen in the care and attention given to the beauty and cleanliness of holy places, the sacred linens and objects used in worship. It will also manifest itself in beautiful ceremonies, chants and the regularity and edifying recitation of the Divine Office.

Nothing is too little, nothing insignificant in the service of such a Lord and King. Let us always remember this! It is a powerful means of apostolate. If the Liturgy is, above all, the praise of the Holy Trinity, offering and sacrifice, a source of divine life—then it is also the most vibrant and effective means of catechizing. Happy the faithful who have a priest who is in love with the liturgy of the Church!

In administering sacred things, we will inspire ourselves with the sentiments of the Church—with Her respect for Our Lord and all that is related to Him, following the example of the Virgin Mary. That means a deep respect, as well as humility and simplicity, avoiding all originality or personal improvisation. Are we so audacious as to think that our personal attitude and way of doing things is preferable to that of the Church?

Liturgical actions are public actions and not personal acts of devotion. We must, therefore, ensure that they are in accordance with the will of the Church and not our own whims, nor those of a reformer inspired by a Protestant spirit.

Let us beware of haste or excessive slowness. Neither edifies the faithful. Let us avoid accumulations of ceremonies, which is against the spirit of the Church. Let us take account of the availability of the faithful in fixing the times of the ceremonies, and also the length of the ceremony when it concerns para-liturgical ceremonies or sermons—that they always have the goal of edifying the faithful rather than satisfying our own desires.

Yet, in this time of secularization, the faithful are sorely afflicted by the need for prayer and to be able to express their faith by processions, pilgrimages, and nocturnal adoration. In these circumstances, pastoral prudence must be correctly exercised in order to arrive at the right measure.

Let us ask the Blessed Virgin to communicate to us her insight on those holy mysteries which she intimately witnessed throughout the course of her earthly life.

+Marcel Lefebvre
September 26, 1982

Article no. 4

In the preceding articles, we have seen that the spirit of the Society is essentially a priestly spirit, enlightened by the radiance of our Redeemer’s Sacrifice on Calvary and in the Mass, the Mystery of Faith. This great mystery, the sun of our faith, is brought to us by the Church’s Liturgy, where, like a mother, She unfolds to us the infinite riches of this mystery, by the actions, words, chants and liturgical vestments, all of which differ according to the remarkable liturgical cycle.

The Society, eager to live out this mystery, zealously seeks to understand the Liturgy and to bring it forth in all its beauty and splendor—Domine dilexi decorum domus tuae. The spirit of the Society is a liturgical spirit.
The consequence of such an approach to God though His redeeming Sacrifice, will produce in the members of the Society the very same effects, within due proportion, that those privileged souls felt who received the stigmata of Our Lord.

There is a twofold effect; wherein the first influences the second, of which it is the source; we speak of contemplative aspects.

  • an ardent desire to offer oneself as a total victim in union with the Divine Victim.
  • a love of God and Our Lord to the point of sacrificing oneself.
  • a total abandonment of oneself to the Holy Will of God.
  • a burning union with the pierced Heart of Our Lord.

The effects of the Spirit of Love, manifested upon the Cross and which continue to manifest themselves at the altar and in the Eucharist, have a tendency to distance a soul from the world, despising material, passing things in favor of eternal, spiritual ones. The soul experiences a great horror of sin, and profound contrition for its faults and a desire to expiate for itself and for others. God must be thanked for communicating to us His spirit of love and victim for the glory of His Father.

How desirable it is for all Society members to thirst after the contemplative life, that is to say, a simple yet ardent glance at the Cross of Jesus, acquiring the spirit of prayer and an interior life comparable to that of Our Lord, Who lived 30 of His 33 years apart from the world.

It is a serious concern for the superiors of Missionary Societies, such as our (which is missionary by necessity, in view of the disastrous situation in the Church today), to note that sometimes certain members, priests in particular, end up abandoning their zeal for the apostolate of prayer, which is leaven and source of the exterior apostolate. The apostolate of prayer is the essential apostolate that unites us to Our Lord, the sole source of the graces of redemption. The exterior apostolate, with its catechism classes, meetings, conferences, etc. will quickly become sterile, if cut off from that fundamental apostolate that keeps us in constant union with our Lord.

Zeal that does not keep an equilibrium and a link between those two apostolates, is in reality a false zeal, a mere human zeal which is no longer humble, for it counts upon human gifts and qualities. Such practitioners of human zeal expose themselves to cruel deceptions, discouragement, irritation and impatience. Their apostolate no longer has a supernatural source. They become like the gardener, who is so carried away by his zeal in watering, then he eventually pulls the hose pipe off the faucet that supplies the water! They also condemn contemplative souls, because they themselves no longer regard contemplation as the foundation of their apostolate. Experience shows this, as does the disaster of renegade priests. A priest who no longer says anything more than his Mass, ends up saying it without devotion and without faith. His apostolate will be fruitless. He is soon to ready to abandon everything.

That is why the Society offers its members a structure, a rule and community life, which keeps them within a true apostolate by a happy balance between the spiritual apostolate and the exterior apostolate. That is what all founders of religious orders or apostolic congregations wanted, conformity to that which the Apostles themselves practiced: "But we will give ourselves entirely to prayer and to the ministry of the word." (Acts 6:4)

+Marcel Lefebvre
January 14, 1982

Article no. 5

The spirit of the Society is the spirit of the Church, the spirit of faith in Our Lord Jesus Christ and in His redemptive work. The entire history of the Church, over the last twenty centuries, reveals the fundamental principles of the Church as inspired by the Holy Spirit, the spirit of Our Lord.

The priest is at the heart of this divine work of the renaissance of souls and their divinization in preparation for their future glory. All his thoughts, ambitions, and actions must be inspired by this spirit of faith. This spirit of faith is essentially a spirit contemplating the crucified and glorified Jesus. The Faith is the seed of the beatific vision, which is an eternally blessed contemplation.

That is why the Church has always encouraged contemplative Orders and has placed them at the head of religious societies. Maria optimam partem elegit[Mary—as opposed to the active Martha—has chosen the greater part—Ed]. The Church also insists upon the prayer of the priest: his breviary, his daily meditation. It is obvious that if the Church officially prescribes this in Canon Law, in that the soul of the priest must belong entirely to Jesus Christ, then the priest must fulfill the four ends of prayer: adoration, thanksgiving, impetration and propitiation.
If contemplation is a glance of love towards the crucified and glorified Jesus, then it places the soul in the hands of God—In manus tuas commendo spiritum meum—and this cannot occur unless we completely abandon our will and place it in God’s hands. In other words, a consummate obedience to His holy will; a will indicated by God and those who legitimately participate in His authority and who use that authority correctly; a will that indicates God’s good pleasure in the course of events that affect the very heart of our existence; illnesses, trials… Let us meditate upon these great instructions of the Church and thereby apply their principles by putting them into practice in our own lives.

This presupposes a deep humility; something that is seen in Benedictine spirituality, which is entirely based upon a progression in the virtue of humility. If the teaching that is contained in the liturgical life is so admirable and draws us towards an ever greater sanctification of soul, then the practical directives of the Church throughout its history, as well as its approval of the many foundations destined to sanctify souls, not to mention the examples of the saints, are all equally precious guidelines for our souls. In following them, according to the grace God grants us, we can be sure of not deceiving ourselves.

Contemplation, obedience, humility, are all elements of one sole reality: the imitation of Jesus Christ and participation in His infinite love.

May we be inspired by these sentiments! Consequently, whatever apostolate we may receive, whatever be the results of our efforts, whatever our limitations or weaknesses may be, we will have the consolation of participating in the joys and sufferings of Our Lord, who will also let us participate in His peace and serenity.

This is, and always will be, the secret fruitfulness of the priestly apostolate.

+Marcel Lefebvre
June 26, 1982

Sunday, September 20, 2015

Lead Up to the Synod - SSPX


At least the SSPX didn't let Mr. Voris' tirade distract them from what is important.


Courtesy of

Context for the Vortex SSPX-Fest


So now Michael Voris' week long tribute the SSPX has concluded.

As I write this ( September 15, 2015), the fest still rages on, but I came across one Harvard lesson that I read today that I think bears repeating here before I examine Mr. Voris' potential motivations for spending a whole week on the SSPX, when the Synod is just around the corner.
Even if an opponents actions make no sense to you, they apparently make sense to him!
Something to keep in mind as we examine what I suspect will be the same old arguments against the SSPX: Schism.

Saturday, September 19, 2015

The Athanasius Question - Mundabor


Mundabor has a good article here that presents the classical precedent for this crisis: St Athanasius.

Athanasius was excommunicated. He continued his job, uncaring. More than that – and something I seldom read about – he and St. Eusebius started appointing bishops of their own, again ignoring the Pope. The bishops they appointed – and I read about that seldom, too – were not bishop without territorial jurisdiction, like the SSPX one. They were bishops in charge of a diocese all right. Nor can it be said that in that world of difficult communications the Pope might not have had control of certain territories. 

So what will happen in the end?  Following the Stockdale Paradox, I am confident that we (ie Faithful Catholics) will prevail, but it is going to be very nasty.


Friday, September 18, 2015

CMTV offers its understanding of schism and Tradical responds


CMTV has posted its thoughts on schism here.  I decided to reply - we'll see if they post my comments. Just in case ... here's what I wrote.

I understand that recently a CMTV moderator stated that the SSPX is formally in schism and that they are all in a state of mortal sin.

Wow, talk about hubris and a lack of catechesis.


Thursday, September 17, 2015

Are the SSPX Confessions Valid - Part 2 Remnant


It is not lost on me that the opponents of the SSPX (CMTV, Mirus, et al) state that the SSPX doesn't have jurisdiction ergo their confessions and marriages are invalid.

This is a half truth.

Yes the SSPX does not claim to have ordinary jurisdiction, otherwise they would be schismatic.

As we've seen, having ordinary jurisdiction is strictly speaking the ordinary or regular way in which the Church grants jurisdiction.  Extraordinarily the Church also grants jurisdiction on a case by case basis in cases of necessity.

From my perspective, there is a grave case of necessity in the Church at this point in time.

Of course, some others will say 'what necessity, this is the new springtime' or 'there is a dire crisis in the Church but it does not amount to a case of necessity because the Pope said it isn't so ...'.

Ok - enough with the delusions.

Objectively (pick any measure) the Church is in crisis and souls are in jeopardy.


Courtesy of the Remnant: Validity of SSPX Confessions Part 2

Wednesday, September 16, 2015

Tuesday, September 15, 2015

Monday, September 14, 2015

Annulments - Catholic Divorce???


Pope Francis definitely wants to make a mess. I agree with Hilary White, and the Church needed a Pope like this in order to get the illness to manifest itself openly!!!

Early on it was claimed that the Church must raze the bastions (V2 razed Doctrine, Consilium razed the liturgy, the Synod and Pope Francis are razing Catholic Morality while deftly undermining Catholic Dogma further).

I pity the pain that will be caused in order to clean up this mess.


Pope Francis has just announced a new and streamlined annulment procedure, but is it open to abuse?
A revised procedure for granting annulments was published on September 8th during a press conference at the Vatican. Published under the title of Mitis Judex Dominus Jesus (“The Gentle Judge, the Lord Jesus”),[1] Pope Francis states that his “concern for the salvation of souls”[2] motivated him to enact these changes.
What is called "annulment" is more properly speaking a “declaration of nullity” which affirms that a bond of marriage never existed between a couple in the first place. The moral certitude of such a declaration must be based upon the review by ecclesiastical judges of the submitted evidence and testimony. Following a declaration of nullity, the parties have the right to marry others with the Church’s blessing if there is no canonical impediment (a circumstance that would forbid matrimony).
Pope Francis’ revision “has substantially altered” a time-proven juridical process and could possibly serve as a “springboard for potential abuse”.[3] The most disconcerting alteration to the annulment process is the removal of the “double confirming sentence,” meaning that a second judgment of nullity was required before the nullity was settled—a safeguard intended to ensure with moral certitude that the marriage bond had never existed.
It was this very point of the traditional juridical process that Cardinal Raymond Burke (former head of the Apostolic Signature, the Church’s “Supreme Court”) defended in the book, Remaining in the Truth of Christ, while citing the chaotic situation which held sway in American dioceses during the ‘70s and ‘80s when this crucial step was de facto omitted.  
We will soon be offering a more in-depth commentary on the problems withMitis Judex Dominus Jesus.
1 Presently the document is only available in Latin and Italian.
2 Cited from Crux article of September 8, 2015: “Pope Francis streamlines process for granting annulments”.

Sunday, September 13, 2015

Cmtv, schism, Bishop Morlino and perspective


Bishop Morlino has apologized for some aspects of his letter concerning the sspx. ( see remnant video courtesy of the remnant).

Pope Francis and the SSPX: Who's On First? - Remnant Newspaper


Well there has been the usual amount of turmoil over the SSPX since Pope Francis' September 1st letter that dealt with an aspect of the SSPX.  There is a whole spectrum of opinion concerning its import for the SSPX and the Church.

Christoper Ferrara has (as usual) a good perspective!


Courtesy of The Remnant

Wednesday, September 9, 2015

Concert Announcement - Tomas Luis de Victoria's 1605 Requiem (September 26th, 2015)


Music reflects the values and culture of the composer and it is obvious that the Tridentine Mass had a profound influence on the composers to create beautiful settings for the Sacrifice of the Mass.

I received a copy of this advertisement from a friend in Winnipeg and encourage all Catholics in the area to attend what, I am certain, will be a wonderful experience.


Tuesday, September 1, 2015

SSPX, Confession and the Year of Mercy


What is the official position of the Church on the sacraments that normally require jurisdiction to be valid (ie Matrimony and Penance).

Up to today - nothing.

As of today - not what most people think ...

"A final consideration concerns those faithful who for various reasons choose to attend churches officiated by priests of the Fraternity of St Pius X. This Jubilee Year of Mercy excludes no one. From various quarters, several Brother Bishops have told me of their good faith and sacramental practice, combined however with an uneasy situation from the pastoral standpoint. I trust that in the near future solutions may be found to recover full communion with the priests and superiors of the Fraternity. In the meantime, motivated by the need to respond to the good of these faithful, through my own disposition, I establish that those who during the Holy Year of Mercy approach these priests of the Fraternity of St Pius X to celebrate the Sacrament of Reconciliation shall validly and licitly receive the absolution of their sins."Source: Rorate-Caeli

Now what is the difference ... well there is an 'uneasy situation' concerning their pastoral situation. For Fr. Zed and CMTV, you need to re-read the document because it neither says the SSPX is in schism, nor does it state that their confessions are invalid.

"Theology of the Body" explained - a Traditional Catholic view - Rorate Caeli


In prep for yet another attack on Catholic Dogma, Doctrine and Morals, I'd like to point out an excellent article posted on Rorate earlier this year: "Theology of the Body" explained - a Traditional Catholic view - Rorate Caeli.

To date my only real reaction the 'Theology of the Body' has been that what little I read doesn't 'feel right'.  The more specific term for this sensation is Cognitive Dissonance or Cultural Dissonance.

In short, what I read of the basic tenets of 'Theology of the Body' seemed to contradict I believed about the Catholic Church's teaching on the purpose of marriage.  The explanations that I received from 'modern' Catholics, didn't do anything to allay my concerns.

This article goes to the heart of why it didn't feel right.